141 Comments

I quit wearing daily makeup when I quit working outside the home. I'm 57 and just wear a tinted moisturizer/sunscreen when I venture out of the house. Nobody has turned to stone from my gaze yet. And I am bitterly disappointed in that.

Expand full comment

Hahahaha. Love it.

Expand full comment

I’m 62 and I stopped wearing almost all makeup in my fifties because it just seemed to accentuate the crinkles and creases. For a while I wore only mascara, but then ditched it too because there’s nothing worse than raccoon eyes. 👀 it’s so freeing to not bother with it! Good job Pamela, more of you and Dawn!

Expand full comment

Over the years, I've become allergic to so many elements in a lot of makeup, so I wear hardly any, and it's very selective. Same thing, no one has run screaming or turned to stone - so it's a Win.

Expand full comment

I think this is the best comment I have ever read

Expand full comment

Thank you. You’ve been spared from the stone gaze.

Expand full comment

Thank you. This is a wonderful take on the stress of appearance.

Your picture is lovely and deeply relatable. I’ve always felt that women are more approachable when we’re not too glamorous. Sometimes I think the strive for glamor puts unintentional wedges between us.

May we all find our confidence!

Expand full comment

Yes! And thank you for saying that. It's been mentioned to me that looking at young women - the ones who are doing the full glamour makeup and the fillers etc - they all look the same. I'm thinking of reality TV stars - the ones our young women find aspirational. Same with online influencers. To me there's something nice about variation and individuality.

Expand full comment

Surgery tends toward monotony as well. If one chooses surgery, and that is a choice that many make, perhaps it would be best to submit for purposes of looking more like oneself than looking like someone else. Just a thought.

Expand full comment

I stopped wearing makeup every day when I was probably 25. I’ve always hated makeup, and I was so over the worry of rubbing my eyes and looking like a raccoon while teaching. I had kids comment for a couple of weeks, but after that, nothing. I would occasionally have girls ask me why I didn’t wear makeup, and I told them you didn’t have to. Some had never been told that, and I hope they remember it. I’m 36 now, I maybe put on mascara for our family pictures once a year. Makeup was never anything I enjoyed, but felt I was expected to do. Now IDGAF. 🤷‍♀️

Expand full comment

It's just what you get used to, right? You must save lots of money, too.

Expand full comment

Ummm… how about we assume women have agency and let them do whatever the flock they wish with their own bodies, including deciding to look skinny, fat and everything in between?

Expand full comment

I agree 100%! But we can't deny the pressure... it takes a lot of strength to exercise our agency, truly.

Expand full comment

Ask any man! Exercise agency?

How about survive?

Expand full comment

Women don’t need makeup. We only think we do because that’s what it seems has been for so long. You look fantastic in your photo! You look like you are aging beautifully. I don’t wear makeup but sometimes wear lipstick for a bit of color on days I’m feeling drab or want to spice it up. We all have natural beauty. Women should not be criticized for how they look as nature made them. The best remedy for this is to do as Pamala does and not give a damn about those who think so small.

Expand full comment

Your “look” is generally for other women. You vamp up for them!

But a deftly applied bit of makeup can draw out natural beauty! Men enjoy a woman who understands that!

Moderation in all things!

Expand full comment

I do not know who glams up for whom. To each her own.

Agree, though, that a little can go a long way. The lovely Pamela Anderson, who I came to admire on learning about her before and after lives, could benefit from a tinted moisturizer to even out skin tone and some lip gloss. That could pass as "no makeup" and she would continue to look beautiful, only a bit more so.

Expand full comment

Please don’t deny evolutionary biology!

There is reason for many behaviors buried in that realm!

Expand full comment

Aside from when I tried in the 9th and 10 grade, I have never worn makeup. I hate it and think it is fake (for me, not judging others.) My hair is white/gray and has been since I was mid 30s. I refuse to dye it. I hear my coworkers talking about spending well over $100 on a haircut and dye. Just… no thanks. I think I’ll be me, even if I am “ugly” to the world.

Expand full comment

I’m sure you’re not ugly! Natural is beautiful!

Expand full comment

I felt the same about Demi’s appearance. I was shocked at how fragile she looked. I was always naturally thin, to the point of looking anorexic. I ate like a pig and never gained weight. Super high metabolism. Menopause took that from me and I’m okay with it. I wear less makeup and don’t always curl my hair. I still feel that I look great for a 64 year old. I’m healthy and that’s what matters most.

Expand full comment

I’ve always been naturally thin too, no matter what I ate! I haven’t met many people like me; glad I’m not the only one 👯

Expand full comment

Thank you for this. I still wear light makeup to the office and events but the rest of the time I am makeup free. I am now a 55 year old wearing less makeup than ever before. Its so liberating! Go Pamela Anderson. I love her strength!

Expand full comment

LOL! Anderson is using an extreme to make a point and receive validation for “being so brave”! “Washed out” is a nice way of saying “you need a touch of makeup, especially around the eyes babe!”

Expand full comment

After the news of Michelle Trachtenberg’s death yesterday, realizing that she was fielding comments about her appearance all while struggling mentally and physically both before and after her liver transplant makes this article hit a little different. Unfortunately many people are always going to see celebrity bodies and faces and public domain. But it made me really step back and think about the EXTREME circumstances that could be happening behind a major alteration in appearance.

Expand full comment

Let's call it what it is. They look anorexic and it's the latest way of disempowering the feminine.

Kudos to Pamela Anderson.

I rarely wear makeup myself as I was blessed with good genes and a healthy complexion. At 68 I feel I need lipstick, eyeliner and mascara but that's about it. For myself to look more like the face I'm used to.

Expand full comment

Great article. I’m so sick of women’s bodies being judged. I am sad to see the trend go back to the anorexic look. And actually, you can tell that those very thin women are not healthy. They have very little muscle. And as we age, muscle is critically important. Check out the work of Dr Gabrielle Lyon and Dr Stacy Sims. They are experts in the importance of muscle to women, especially post menopausal women. Women who waste away like this are shortening their lives.

Expand full comment

Yes, I interviewed Stacy Sims for my second book; I respect her work a lot. I'm a big fan of getting strong. :)

Expand full comment

OMG! Demi is literally living her art! 🤣😂

Expand full comment

I love this! As a newly 67 yo, I feel the same way. I never wore a lot of makeup. It may have come from my teen years when my mom and dad said I could wear it if they couldn’t tell I had it on. As an adult, I used neutral colors and little to no foundation. Rarely did I wear lipstick and found when I did it seemed to disappear. In my late forties,I got a stye and then another. Over time, I decided to stop wearing mascara and eyeliner. For the last five years or so, I wear no make up. I have friends who’ve had Botox and fillers done. I notice their mouths begin looking like Nicole Kidman’s. I’ve seen so many beautiful women turn into something else in the attempt to remain youthful. Not me. I am what I am. Great article!

Expand full comment

Absolutely love your take! 💗 rock on!

Expand full comment

Thank you for writing and sharing this! Finding balance as a woman, in a world that has always held women’s agency and self assurances at arms length, is a constant exploration. Shout out Pamela Anderson for choosing for herself, and inspiring others as well!

Expand full comment

Nikki, I saw Demi and immediately thought about Tom Wolf's Bonfire of the Vanities where he describes the women as coat hangers....

Expand full comment

"x-ray" women was also one of Wolfe's apt descriptions, along with "starved to perfection." Decades later his work continues to nail it.

Expand full comment

I would have never reocgnized Demi or Brooke had you not named them in those photos. Thin is not beautiful. And it makes them appear desperate. I wish with all that I am that women could just age gracefully, embracing their gray hair and lines and lumps without the world ripping them apart over it. Pamela is lovely bare-faced, and you are as well.

Expand full comment

Demi looks OK, at least in these photos, but I did not recognize Brooke Shields. She is about a decade shy of late Madonna-hood, but she could salvage herself by dropping out of this ghoulish journey now. Here is hoping.

Expand full comment